Episode transcript
Parag Dixit
Hi Mudit, how are you?
Mudit
I'm well. How are you?
Parag Dixit
Going very well. How are things going with you now?
Mudit
Things are going well. Mixed personal lot going on the personal front, and it's been a turbulent year. So there's a lot of things going on. Effort on a lot of places.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, exactly. There's anxiety
Mudit
generally in the market.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely right. No, absolutely right. And that's what we are all here for. But welcome back to our podcast guys, we'll actually discuss exactly what Modi has been talking right now, and you see it's all over the place. Property prices are rising, have been falling. In fact, interest rates are rising, and now even unemployment is going to rise. And that's like as if as if you're all getting attacked from all the sides. Property market is getting smashed around. But the bigger question which we are going to target today is: Are property prices getting impacted more because people are losing their jobs, or is it still the interest rate which is the biggest culprit right now? And more importantly, maybe I'll ask you, Mudit, very before we start, is is this rising unemployment and this what's happening there? That's is it something which is going to create something more serious, or is it something which is interest rates, which is a bigger issue?
Mudit
That's an interesting one, Parag. You know what? A lot of times people differentiate and say unemployment and interest rates are two separate things. But if you look closely, these are very very interconnected. If you look at interest rates, right? Interest rates, if once they start increasing, they reduce the borrowing capacity. Correct. Yeah. They for people who already have a mortgage, they also reduce their they increase their repayments. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But at the same time, let's say if businesses are struggling, yeah. And if businesses are not able to meet their expenses, they will let go of some people. They will have job losses, and which results in unemployment, right? Yeah. Now imagine a homeowner, somebody who's dealing with higher mortgage rates, and also there's a risk of job, risk of losing the income.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah.
Mudit
That's when it becomes more serious.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely right. No, I agree with you on this, and that's that's the worst part is that for some people, you know, falling property prices add on to the disaster. You know, they are getting even more. But for some people, it's it's an opportunity. Some people start saying, "Okay, I have missed out on maybe the last couple of cycles where I because I could make money or I could get a property growth or an equity or something." But you you know, no, you don't really know whether it's a genuine buying opportunity in front of me, or is this something which is a falling knife and I don't want to catch it. I mean, things are going to become even worse right now, and that's what we people start worrying about, right?
Mudit
No, absolutely. That's what we want to explore today, and I think a lot of people will be surprised by what we're discussing. See, sometimes what happens is that the biggest risk is that losing a job, right? Not the price increase, but losing a job. But I think it's a little bit before that. It's the fear, it's the care that I might lose my lose my job, and that's where it gets worse off.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely right. Actually, the event itself, before the event, even this, then you start fearing that this is going to come and hit me. It doesn't hit everyone, but you start fearing that it's going to come and hit me, and then you start thinking, "All right, I don't want to get into this, or I just want to keep a status quo. I just get into an inertia. I don't want to move anywhere." And anyway, so if if I will look at what you're saying, and let's let's start from here. If I start looking at what the unemployment market talks of, we're talking of about 4.7%, which we have already reached, and that's about 39,000 people, if I'm not wrong. Which which which employment had fallen by that number, 39,300, I think. This and this unemployment was still higher. The number of people employed is still higher by 1.2% from the previous year. So unemployment has fallen, but the total number of people who are employed is still higher than the previous year. Now, but still, okay. Let's let's not go there. Let's stick to the 39,300 people. Now, if you read it like this, you start feeling okay. 40,000 people have lost their job in a month, and that's a big alarm. Now, how do we really interpret those numbers?
Mudit
I think absolutely right. See, the number of 40,000 is there, but we need to understand what does it actually represent. Yeah, because when we talk about 40,000 people made redundant, what does it mean? It means people who have been leaving the workforce, people migration contracts ending, so it's a mix of all of that. Okay, so 40,000 people doesn't mean that today suddenly these 40,000 people have become people who own a mortgage and they can't afford it straight away. Okay, yeah, yeah. In fact, if you look at it, the trend unemployment rate, it was 4.6%. So yes, yes, there are signs of weakness in the market in terms of labor and employability. Yeah, yeah. But when we look at this number, we need to be. We need to understand that what does it actually mean?
Parag Dixit
Yeah, true, true, true. That that's rightly said. That it doesn't. It should not raise an alarm in my mind that oh my God, 39,000 jobs have been lost. It should really. It's it's not. It doesn't really mean that. So many people are now not will not be able to pay their mortgages. It just is a number which which is a different different representation from what we're understanding. No,
Mudit
absolutely. In fact, if you look at ABS data for for August 2026, there were roughly 325,000 job. Okay, so yes, all right, yes, which was a little bit down from the May, but businesses are looking to hire workers. It's just that it could be different sectors in which employment is increasing, some different sectors in which employment is going down a bit. So that is where it we need to understand what the number 40,000 is not straight away an alarm in itself.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah. So it's it's not like that 49,000 people have lost their job, and there is no other job available. There is around 300,000 jobs available, but yeah, which sector which you have lost may not be the sector which is hiring, or there is a change in employment trends or something. Okay, okay. Let me ask you another question. So, if if this unemployment isn't rising dramatically, but still, you know, there is still a weaker employment market. It's it's there for everyone to see. We can't unsee it. There's a weaker employment market. Does it is it still impacting the property market? Because people don't don't necessarily need lose their job to buy. Then they stop buying a property. Is that right?
Mudit
100% correct. Okay. Let me let me explain it by an example. Okay. Let's say there's a there's a couple. They've been saving money to buy a house. Okay. Let's say both of them combined earn a family income of $200,000. Yeah. Yeah. And the house they wanted to buy was let's say $900,000.
Mudit
Now they have saved the money, and one of them gets to know that the company is restructuring. Yeah. Okay. All right. Yeah. They have the savings. They have seen properties. They are liking properties. They know what their expenditures are. Yeah, yeah. And they and and this person has not lost the job yet. One of them. They have heard the company's restructuring, but not lost the job yet. It's just a news. But because what's all is going in the market?
Mudit
Would you think that they will be confident enough to buy a house in this situation? Pretty fast.
Parag Dixit
Good question. I don't think so. Right? They they might. I maybe you'll delay the purchase or maybe change your budget to say okay only let me try and fit with one person's income or something or just or just wait or just freeze and just wait it out.
Mudit
100% correct. So it's not about that I have to lose my job and then only it will strike me. It's about the fear of unemployment in a market like this. When you hear news, when you see news, when you hear in your friend circle of somebody, you know that they have lost their job. Then that fear comes in, and that's what starts changing things for you.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, cool. So I I get what you're saying. So two two things which I just quickly take away from what you've just said, so it's not the unemployment which is impacting the market as much. It's one, obviously, there is an actual income loss which is there if somebody loses their job. So that's one which is there. But second is the bigger impact is the confidence. Lack of confidence you get into the market because you just you just don't want to take a decision. You just want to stay away from anything and just, just there's a bit of gloom into it and into it. Yeah,
Mudit
100% correct. And the second one, this fear is more, much more powerful than actually losing the job. Yeah. So that is where the whole market sentiment changes.
Parag Dixit
That's where the whole market sentiment changes. You're so right. In the end, I need to have certainty around stuff. In in the end, I need to feel positive to to a property decision is a life changing decision whether it's an owner occupied or an investment property. If I am not up to it, if I just can't think straight, it's very likely that I will just not take any kind of a decision and I'll just freeze on what what what's been happening all around. Yeah,
Mudit
no, 100% correct. But that's on the unemployment front. And let's I mean, the second big one is the interest rates, right? Now, interest rates have gone up. They are like the highest in more than a decade now. Yeah. The cash rate has been increased by RBA to 4.85%. If you look at totality reports for how the property values are, in October they fell by 1.2%. So I think overall since May the fall has been close to six to 7% on an average. So there are certain pockets, certain cities, certain sectors where the fall has been double digits. There are certain places where it is a smaller number. So I think that's the big question. So see, if unemployment is only gradually increasing, right? But the interest rate has been sharply going up.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah. So is
Mudit
that interest rate a more is a bigger factor towards the market that we are seeing right now? That is that is why I think that's important to understand.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, you know, fair. That's fair. That's fair. That's a fair point. Now, and I'll I'll ask you something maybe in in a little while on this, but maybe it's a fair point what you're saying because interest rates are an immediate pressure on me. It rises, and I've got 300, 400, 500 bucks per month increasing now. Let's say if I've got to say 640 k kind of a mortgage on me, and with and the interest itself, if I'm paying from say if I was paying five and a half percent earlier, it would be. About 3600 or something per month as a repayment, and if I go to six and a half, which is 1% higher over all this last one year. In fact, now after this one, it's 1.25. But let's say 1.1% higher. Then I'm paying about 400 bucks higher per month as a repayment on that. Correct. And that's a lot of money which is coming on to me, which is which is impacting me. It changes my mind that okay maybe I'm going to bear this 400 bucks but what after this?
Mudit
Absolutely. See, it is straight away 5,000 $5,000 a year. Your you have not lost your job. Your income hasn't changed. Your savings, I mean, your expenses, other other expenses are almost similar, gone up a bit because of inflation. But then there's a sudden pressure on you, right? So you're doing the same work as last year,
Parag Dixit
yeah, yeah.
Mudit
But now because the inflation is higher and the interest rates have gone up, your savings have dropped. So it's an immediate pressure.
Parag Dixit
It's an immediate pressure. Now you're right, and so and and you you're right because interest rate will affect maybe in 1000s and 1000s of millions of borrowers at same point of time, but unemployment will only affect that number of people at that point of time. And like like we rightly said, some some of them are going to get job next next month or two months down the line or three months down the line or something of like that. But again, there are new buyers as well. So somebody who's now coming to the market fresh, and when banks will check their borrowing, they find that their borrowing capacity is going down, and they they start filing. Okay, now you could buy something worth 700,000 earlier, but now I've come back, and they've not lost the job. They've nothing nothing has changed, but borrowing capacity has gone down, and now I can buy say 600 or 650 k, and some something like that is starting to change, and I start losing confidence. I say, okay, I don't know what's happening with the job front. I've heard my friend lost his job. I heard my uncle's friend lost their job, or something, and I don't know what's going to happen. And then this AI bubble, and there's all that stuff which you read in the market, and then suddenly you find that okay, I'm not too sure. What do I want to do? Yeah,
Mudit
and suddenly, if see if if you see that if hundreds of 1000s of people buyers, yeah, they start experiencing similar thing at the same time when the market is like that, yeah, then automatically the demand goes down. Yeah, in context of property, when there are property listings in the market, yeah, there will be lesser offers made to properties. The sellers will receive lesser offers. That will put a pressure on the sellers, right? So that's how the property market gets impacted directly when the confidence overall is going down.
Parag Dixit
You're true. You're true. Now that's right. So interest rates will definitely impact property prices. This this this is a no-brainer. It does that. But unemployment, when it starts rising significantly. The pressure will multiply. It will become even more. And maybe, maybe, maybe if I would like to put it like that, the high interest rates that will reduce my affordability of how much I can pay. But unemployment will reduce my ability to pay anything at all. 100%. There, I'm just getting reduced by a percentage, by a proportion. But here, it just goes off. It completely goes off, and that's a much bigger problem when it comes in. And that that's that's something which impacts you straight away when it hits your mind.
Mudit
Straight away, and till the time you get a job again, you are just in that stress. And even when you get the new job, for some time you still like okay, I just got into a new one. There is still uncertainty. You are on probation, and all of that happens, right? So see, interest rates they put pressure on the market through the problem of affordability. Your affordability goes down. Yeah, but you rightly said unemployment put pressures through that security itself, the income security. That am I safe? Is it okay to stretch? And that's where it's a problem. And when both of these come together, in a market like today's, then the effect is a multiplier.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, but see, all said and done, I understand what we're talking on interest rates, we're talking on unemployment, and we'll get deeper into what we are discussing. But we also have to remember property prices; they don't change only by these one or two parameters. There is always the fundamental issues in property of supply, demand, population growth, construction, socio-economic factors, and so on and so forth. So interest rates cannot define every movement which is happening in the property market. Correct. Similarly, unemployment also cannot decide any improvement, any kind of a change in the property market. And it's these are all not the only factors. The basic fundamentals of properties that doesn't change at all, right?
Mudit
No, 100%. You're absolutely right. Property markets are much more complex. The price is is impacted by a lot of other lot of other factors. Otherwise, otherwise, whenever the interest rates increases, directly the property price should go down, or vice versa. Correct. It is not directly. There's a correlation, strong correlation, inverse correlation, but it is not just 100% direct, right? Correct. So, I think what is important to understand is that what happens in such. Markets to buyer psychology. I think because fundamentals of properties are not changing. Yes. So those fundamentals are there. Supply, demand, those the demand is impacted a bit because of the buyer psychology. So when I think my question to you is that how much of this market actually the change in the market is driven by the confidence, the buyer confidence.
Parag Dixit
Very fair question. In fact, it's a it's it's a big question, and there's a huge amount of impact which happens because of confidence. Because eventually, anything which we do in life, if we are not really feeling confident about it, we'll not do it. It's it's very simple as a person who even if it's I'm I'm I'm not if this is this is lovely delicious piece I put in front of me, but I'm not, I'm not happy with it for some reason. I won't, I'm not going to eat it. And property is probably one of the biggest financial commitments which I'll do in my entire life. Any Australian, average Australian will ever make. And an average person buys maybe one or two or three properties in your life, right? They're not going to do too much, and you're getting a 35-year, 30, 25, 30-year mortgage, which you're getting into it. That just see two people, okay? Just, just, just maybe imagine two friends, okay? One of them, good job, everything, very stable industry. Second one, same salary, maybe getting a higher bonus, something. But then you find out, okay, my, I'm, I'm working in David Jones, and I'm going to get into redundancies, and there's a problem which is happening in the company. And same deposit, same money, same living expenses, good friends, similar loans today. But who's going to buy?
Mudit
See, no brainer. That if the if the confidence on on the security of income is not there,
Parag Dixit
yeah, then it
Mudit
is very difficult for to imagine that the person two will buy right now.
Parag Dixit
Correct. Right. So if the person two is not going to buy, then that's where we get into an issue, and that's where we need to understand that. That's why it we need to look at beyond the unemployment numbers. It's just not the unemployment. It's the employment, maybe confidence, which matters a lot about there. When people get worried about their future, they are not going to take major financial decisions. They are going to stall. They are going to stay. They are going to freeze, and they are going to say, "Let me conserve what I have. Let me prepare for those rainy days, and let me just hold on to what I have today and not worry about it. Maybe my time will come later."
Mudit
Absolutely, people will be okay to buy. Let's say make small decision. They'll be happy to buy $20 coffee every day, for example.
Parag Dixit
Right, but
Mudit
the moment there is fear of that uncertainty, the confidence, then big decisions. Yeah, house is probably the biggest biggest purchase of your life. Yeah, that suddenly you it puts a big spanner on that decision. 100%, 100%. No,
Parag Dixit
that's that's there's a big serious lesson which we all have learned in these times. I think if if buyers are going to become very cautious, which they are right now in today's market, we'll see very few people attending inspections. We'll have very few offers going out to properties. We'll have higher days on market, higher inventory which is lying in the market will have longer selling periods. We'll have buyers get more negotiating powers, but again, sellers also will decide whether I want to sell or not, and whether I can hold on to that property or not. And this pushes prices lower even before we actually see an unemployment rising. This is the fear and the confidence itself is driving the property market down, right?
Mudit
100%. So, see, in such markets, even if there is, let's say, no increase in supply, okay,
Speaker 1
but
Mudit
but because of the employment pressure, the demand goes down.
Speaker 1
Yeah,
Mudit
it puts a pressure on the demand. The demand goes down.
Parag Dixit
Yeah,
Mudit
even if the supply is weak, doesn't matter.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely correct. Now, in fact, you're so right. Then supply becomes weak because supply becomes weak because there are sellers who say, "Okay, all right, I can hold on to my property. I don't want to sell it. I just withdraw it unless I have a stress on me. Unless there is a problem which is going to come to me. Unless there is a deadline which I am following. Unless there are life issues, separating something of that sort, I won't have anyone to accept lower offers. Why will I do that? I will. I will, and then you will start seeing transaction volumes go down, days on markets go increasing, and prices become the later point of discussion in in all of this.
Mudit
Yeah, yeah. Prices prices become secondary. It's about that whether I have the capability, capacity, and that confidence to buy right now, and I think the unemployment
Parag Dixit
it
Mudit
starts becoming a stress in terms of mortgage, and that's where it is important to understand that when does the unemployment it becomes a stress in terms of what's going to happen now,
Parag Dixit
true, true, very, very different. Correct, you're so right, and that's when the market is very different in the times when unemployment causes forced selling. The market mostly revolves around when unemployment is is causing you know discomfort, and there's a lot of. Selling selling pressures are not there, or people are withdrawing, and all that chaos happens. But there are times when it becomes a huge mortgage stress, and that's that's where it becomes a problem.
Mudit
No, no, absolutely. So let's let's go to the. I think that's the most important part of that of this discussion. That what happens when someone actually loses the job, right? One is their fear, but then somebody, somebody actually losing a job, because often you hear everybody saying that when there's an increase in unemployment, it will create forced sales. Yeah, it will create which will eventually crash the property prices, right? If there are forced sales and then property prices crashes. Is it is it really like that? Is it does it happen straightforward like that?
Parag Dixit
I don't think. I think there is a whole lot of stuff which happens. There is a big process. Maybe I think we should which follows before someone is forced to sell their property. Let's let's let me take let me take an example. Okay, a friend of mine, million dollar property which he has, $800,000 mortgage on it, 80%. Okay, both of them are working. Husband, wife are working. All good. Income is 200,000. Like he said at the start, suddenly one of them loses their job. Okay, now what are they going to? They can't just sell it just like that. They can just. They won't just. They won't throw it away if one of them lose their job. They'll try and do something around it.
Mudit
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, in this, let's say if they have an interest rate of six and a half percent, a 30-year loan, their repayment will be let's say close to $5,000 a month.
Mudit
Now, if the household income goes down from let's say 200,000 to 110,000, $120,000.
Mudit
See, their mortgage will continue. They will have to continue the repayment. Bank is not going to let go of the money that they have lent to them. What will what will eventually these people do? First of all, I mean, automatically, naturally, the thing is that okay, let's tide over this time somehow. How can we do it? One, let's try and reduce our expenses. Whatever are discretionary expenses, let's try and look at them and reduce them. Recreation, entertainment, some extra classes for kids. Let's say now eating out. All of those things you can start cutting down a bit. You say, okay, we were doing some savings earlier. Let's let this is a time when we may not be able to save. Yeah. Yeah. If you have some some buffer in your bank account. You say, okay, in this time I will dip into my savings a bit, but I don't want to lose my house. I will continue repaying till the time I can. Yeah, I don't want to let the house go off my kids, my family's head. Right. So you will, you will try and do whatever possible from that one income, and parallelly keep looking for options so that you can. I mean, this is obvious. This is what mostly everybody would do.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, absolutely correct. And they can also connect with their lenders or their bankers for for getting help. Right. The
Mudit
lenders. A lot of times, approaching lenders is possible. You can talk to them about deferral payments. You can talk to them about some kind of restructuring during that period, the stressful period. There could be temporary payment arrangements. So these are things that can be done and asked for from the lender. But of course, lender to lender, there will be variation. Interest will not go away. You will probably be charged. There are chances that the interest rate may actually be higher. Yeah. When you go back to your normal payment schedule, when your job is back, then you may end up paying a little bit higher money. So those are things which are possible. But in such scenarios, now imagine two families. Let's say one family had a savings of $70,000 in their bank account. The other family has a saving of only $5,000 in the bank account. In such times, there will be very very different outcome for these two families.
Parag Dixit
True. True. So you you're so right. The the it will all depend upon how much savings they have. The person with seven grand or five grand saving in their bank account are going to really really struggle. So same same jobs, but losing a job in both these families will have very different outcomes. Like you rightly said,
Mudit
100%. And and so see, it's not only about. I think the stress is not only about the income. The stress is about the income and what your expenses and liabilities and what your lifestyle is. So it's the difference, and plus the kind of support which may be available either from the lender or from your family, friend circle, whoever. Yeah, I think that plays a bigger role,
Parag Dixit
100%. That plays a large role into all of this, and like like we we were just talking about this. It's not you don't go into force selling at this point of time as well. There is there's a lot of things, a lot of water has to flow over the bridge before you start getting into force selling. You know, and situations do arise. It's not that they don't arise, and you will you will seeing that Combank has been talking that the mortgage arrears are now reaching at 14-year high. But that's not that's just arrears. That's not forced sales. If you're looking at one of the NAB reports, I think they have about 150 properties which they had which they have in their possession, which is not high when you look at the total countries. One, so. Some people do get into forced selling, and then that's where the job losses are there, and they're not just not able to get back into employment at all, and their income is so dramatically reduced that they have to eat first, and they just can't pay mortgage, or the cash flow pressures are so much that you just can't come over it. That really, then then you kind of start getting into it. You say, okay, my I've dipped into savings. I've taken my assistance. Some people stabilize at this point of time. Some people cannot stabilize at this point of time. If they cannot stabilize at that point of time, and you keep on having an issue in making repayments, then you talk to the lender and say, okay, get me an arrangement or something. If that arrangement is also not able to come work out, and you're still not getting an employment. If you're still into an issue, that's I think this time frame itself is six to eight months, or maybe 12 months from where you had started off getting into trouble when their employment. Maybe I'm not putting a time frame to it, but generally this will pass through this point of time. Then you go back to the lender and say, okay, here I'm I'm I'm just surrendering my property, or lender will say, okay, why don't you put it in the market? It's it's not too tough to put it into the market. You can sell it at a loss. Maybe maybe not sell it at the same price which you bought it for, but sell it at loss. But you can still be all right with that. Or you can just say, I just can't do that. You take the property away. Maybe the lender takes the property away. Away, but it's it's it's a later option. It's a later option. There's so many things which is available to people before they actually get into a default. No, no,
Mudit
100%. I think it's a. It's you're absolutely right. There's a. It's important to make that distinction between somebody who's facing a little stretch during this period versus the reposition of the property and the forced sale.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So
Mudit
it's a it's a distinction. These two are different scenarios. Yeah, there's a longer period available here. You can try out extra saving. Yeah, I mean, right, less saving is less expenses. Yeah, try maybe driving an Uber for the part time for some time. Whatever way, whatever way you'll you'll try and manage somehow. Lenders help in terms of repayment structuring and all that, so I think yeah, absolutely right. We need to see the see. I think what we need to see is that the mortgage arrears, if they are increasing, yeah. How are the how are the hardship arrangements going on? What is the increase in the hardship arrangements from different banks and lenders? Are they getting more common? How are the listings number of listings? Which how many of them are distressed listings? I think these are some indicators we need to see to to understand a bit more about that. Really, how many are forced into force sale kind of scenario? How many people are going through that and are beyond that no stretch? Yeah, yeah.
Parag Dixit
Only then you can actually put a finger to it. They're saying that okay, unemployment is really really causing the property market to fall, but but I think the the risk at this point of time starts becoming a bit more serious. If more and more houses start getting into this issue that they are losing income and they are reaching to a stage that some of them say I have no other choice but I have to sell my industry where I used to work is all gone. I have to sell. That's where people start getting worried, and not only them, there are other buyers also in that whole area, on that whole community, on that whole bit starts getting worried about their jobs as well. So if both of them are happening together, then we are into an issue. We will have more people wanting to sell. Sellers are highly motivated. They just want to come out of the property because of all these issues. Buyers are now losing confidence. Yeah,
Speaker 1
less funds. And
Parag Dixit
that creates a huge gap, and that will create a a big downward pressure on how the properties are there. And you don't want to get into that situation where there is so much of a gap between people who want to sell and the people who want to buy.
Mudit
No, no, 100%, absolutely. So, see, the real danger is not in just unemployment rising; it's when the unemployment rises to a threshold where it results in distress selling, while at the same time, the demand is weakening. That is where the problem lies.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely correct. No, that's you so right. And then there is another factor to this very important factor, which I'll just bring to light. That if if I had bought this property originally by paying a small deposit, let's say I was in that 5% first home guarantee scheme, or I had generally taken a 98%, 95% loan at that point of time because my deposit was lower. That's where I get into issue because I cannot refinance, I cannot sell because now I'm into negative equity. If I'm into negative equity, that will really impact us. So and so, it's very very important that we understand when we are buying the property because you can't cure it at the point of sale. You can only cure it at the point of purchase. You know, a good when you're looking at that and you talk to a good mortgage broker, the good mortgage strategy will not be only about getting the loan approved from them. The good mortgage strategy will be to ensure how will you. Manage the loan when when when things happen in life. They don't go as per what you're planning to do. And what do you do then? How do you manage it? And what do you what are what will be your next steps? And what will be your plan B? Life is not going to be always rosy, but what's my plan B? And how will I be able to afford? Or I'm going to live on the edge for forever?
Mudit
Absolutely. Sometimes sometimes you see that boring till the neck, and I mean there are so many, so many stories. Or I mean, if you look at yeah, I mean so many stories around it that how much how much is okay? I mean, how much should you stretch from generations? This has been passed on to us. But now, Parag, another thing I I want to move on to the another important thing, which is about the national picture, about the property market as such. Now, okay, okay, it's it's not a homogeneous market that we have. Correct. Yeah, that's right. Different states, different cities, capital cities, then significant urban areas, regional markets. They all behave differently, right? So, is there is there a difference between when we are talking about rising rising unemployment, right? Is there a difference between some areas versus some other areas, or is it very very all alike? We put everything in the same bucket and say everything is is a problem now.
Parag Dixit
I don't. I think it's a good good point. Very good point because see, investors have to be very careful about what they are doing. You cannot treat everything as the same. Australia is not a one property market at all. Every state has its own things. You know, every you can take let's say two suburbs or two locations or two cities in different states, and one city can one city can have a lot of a lot of employment opportunities. You know, healthcare and education and mining and professional services and retail and logistics and all, and the other one it's a let's say there's a regional town which is dependent on one thing, maybe a larger mining activity or larger one
Mudit
single
Parag Dixit
industrial activity or single project kind of thing. Now, when all of these kind of things impact, now you can easily see where we will have a larger impact, right? Whether in the first one where they have you have diversified employments, or in the second one where you are living in a town which has only one employment, right?
Mudit
No, absolutely. The the option B is clearly a higher risk because if because of some reason that project stalls because of any reason, the market reason, whatever. Then there's a risk on the employment of all these people of the entire town itself. If the whole town is dependent on that project, whether it's a mine or defense, something or infrastructure, then that's a big problem there. It's a big problem there,
Parag Dixit
and it spills over. It spills over to the retail shops, to the coffee shops, to the pub. It spills over to the groceries. It spills over everywhere, and into it's become more uniform across all property values in that particular area, and that's where we have to think of how when we are looking at a particular property to buy in a particular area, we need to see if that project finishes off there. If that activity finishes off there, people will leave, and then all those good glossy high rental values and high rental yields will disappear because there are no people there. There's nobody to rent it, and it's it's not even worth the paper. It is it's been on right, and that creates a serious issue. And that's where always we have to say that when you're getting into regional or something, you need to be aware of what is it. Diversified employment has always been the most important factor to look at when you go into regional.
Mudit
100%. I think that's where a lot of regional locations in Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, Western Australia, a lot of these regional locations become important to understand that what's going on there, because some of these locations do have very very high rental yields. We're still talking about 7%, 8%, 9%, 10% kind of rental yields, but higher rental yield versus the kind of risk which is there. These are two completely different things. True. True. It is not always as rosy as it looks. So on the on the Excel spreadsheet projections of cash flows can look very attractive, but then where is the risk calculated in that? What is the risk of that? Absolutely
Parag Dixit
correct. No, you you're so right. You're bang on on that. I I can get an 8%, 7%, 9% kind of a rental yield, but if my property is vacant for three months, then that seven, 8%, 9% is already down to six or five or something like that, and then if you if you find that the number of people who were living in that area have disappeared or have reduced or there's something the tenant pool is reduced, then my rents are going to go down. That gross rent, which I'm talking of 789, or whatever, that's going to become maybe 345, and that's and then you factor in the vacancy rates, then I'm I'm no more into the profitable situation where I was when you were when I had thought when I had started getting into properties like that.
Mudit
And it is not only about cash flow. It if if the market is such, then the long-term capital growth, which was a rosy picture, which was shown, that also gets impacted. That also gets
Parag Dixit
impacted. Absolutely correct. So whenever. We look and whenever we say that you should assess a location or a suburb or an area, you have to have to start with employment diversity, diversity which is there. How many how many industries are there which are supporting the local income? Very important to know. Is the population growing in that area? Very important to know. Is there reverse migration? Extremely important to know. Are there more permanent jobs there, or more temporary jobs there, more casual jobs there. So it's like long-term employment or not very important. No, is more housing supply coming into that market or not? Extremely important. And then even more important is what is the profile of the people who are actually renting there? Who are the renters? Is it students? Is it is it a good job person or is it just a casual person? Is it somebody who's just there for three months, four months? Is it an Airbnb or just a holiday thing? What is it there?
Mudit
No, I think that's a very good point. So because a suburb with strong healthcare, strong education, strong services, strong government employment. I think automatically the risk of that suburb or that city is far lower than a suburb or a city which is dependent on a single single project, single employment. 100%.
Parag Dixit
100%. I so agree with you on this that diversity of employment is extremely important. Whenever affordability will get stressed, borrowing will get declined, or supply will be there. Prices definitely will will soften, but employment will will remain only one part of the equation. That will not become the entire equation in itself, and that is important to understand because if employment becomes such an overwhelming factor on that, then you're not investing into properties. Then you are, then you are just maybe gambling there, or just just taking a punt if something is going to go right or not.
Mudit
No, 100%. And a lot of times, I think what investors need to realize is that if a property is cheap, yeah, because of I mean, I think it's important to understand what's the reason of it being cheap. So cheap doesn't mean good value by default. You have to look at what is fundamentally what is going on in the market. Is there what is the reason of it being cheap? Is it cheap because there are problems, structural problems in that area, supply demand issues, or is it cheap because maybe the the the person who's selling, there's some life situation there, and or maybe it's that particular time the market is such like that, right?
Parag Dixit
Absolutely correct. Now, now it's a good point which you picked up, and so when you see such properties that the property is cheap or the property is fallen by say 15 20% in their property value, which which you may find in these times today's times, you have to start seeing that is it now an opportunity, or is it is it a warning which is coming to me? Is it is it something which is now getting fundamentally wrong in that area, or I am saying okay, I am back to a market which is two year ago prices, and there's nothing wrong in this market except for sentiment which is transitioning right now, so let me invest, and that's where we have to start always thinking that sometimes when and we spoke about it at the start. Sometimes when you are thinking and you are saying unemployment is rising and there is people who are getting worried and they are not buying, there are some people who know my job stability is extremely high, and it creates an employment opportunity for me, and that's that's something which is the other side of
Mudit
the. See, we have spoken about risks. I think that is quite clear. What are the risks there? But then, in times like this, the question is because a lot of investors ask this that it's uncertain,
Parag Dixit
it's risky for some people. Is it an opportunity for me to buy. Is it a market where I should buy? Yeah, I mean that becomes very specific. It is very subjective. It's not generally for everybody. Yeah, because everybody is going through their own security and income and all that, right? So could rising unemployment actually create opportunities for a certain set of people? That's I think that's the key point there, right? Yeah, yeah, 100%. No, that's that's right. See, person's garbage is the other person's, you know, treasure, and it's always like that. Some people find that okay, this is my misery, and some people say, oh, that's my opportunity. But we should be very careful about how we define opportunity. Like you rightly said, cheaper property is not an opportunity. We let's say a property was worth say say 800,000 some time ago, and now it's become 740. So you're getting a 60 grand discount. So you say okay, it's somewhere around 8% discount which I am getting, but it looks attractive. Obviously, it looks attractive. But we need to know why why the prices have fallen there. Yeah, and is it something intrinsic or is it something transient? And that's going to be important when we are looking at whether I'm going to buy that property and I'm going to encash that opportunity, or not going to encash that opportunity into in that point of time.
Mudit
Exactly. I mean, is it because the higher interest rates have reduced the buyer demand for the time being? Is that the main reason, or is it because local economy is going down? And people are leaving that area, so there are structural fundamental problems in that area. So, what is causing that?
Parag Dixit
True. So, just rightly said. So, if in the first case, if the only the interest rates are impacting, and there's a good diversity of employment there, and there is limited housing supply, and there's a good stable rental demand, why not? It's a good opportunity. It's as soon as it corrects, I am going to get good money and be able to create a good equity out there. But if some area is permanently losing jobs, irrespective of the interest rates or whatever is happening, population is going down, tenants is going down. I think this is too risky for anyone to really look at that and to even think of it as an opportunity to invest at that point of time, correct?
Mudit
No, no, 100. Okay, I have a linked question on this. Let's say when the unemployment is on the rise,
Parag Dixit
yeah,
Mudit
wouldn't that increase the rental demand? I mean, so because of higher unemployment, lesser people we are saying will be able to buy because of income insecurity, right? Yeah. So it puts pressure on the rental demand because they would continue renting for a long time. So wouldn't that increase the rental demand and the rental yield? And that it gives for an investor that's a good thing.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, that's a that's a very that's a that kind of is possible. It's it's not that it's not possible, but in the end, it may just do that as well. That it may have some people continuing to rent for life, you know, or maybe for a longer, longer period of time. But again, see, if you look at this fundamentally, we are saying people are going to lose their jobs. If they're going to lose their jobs, they're going to lose their income. If they're going to lose their income, they won't be able to afford the rent as well. They may downsize. They may get into shared accommodation, or they may relocate to find a job, and they will have to move out because my industry doesn't operate in that city anymore. So I have to go out somewhere. So it it may not be that employment is increasing. So I'm not buying. So my rental demand is going to increase. It may not automatically mean that from with that perspective.
Mudit
So I I should not look at only the vacancy rates, but I should also understand that who are the possible tenants and what is the nature of the tenants and what is their capacity to pay.
Parag Dixit
Absolutely correct. Absolutely correct. And you see that all the time. See, whenever we you'll have an investment property and your property manager is going to put the property on rent, they will. They good property managers will always assess what are the financial capabilities of the tenants, and they'll say, "Oh, these guys are earning this kind of an income, so it looks stable." And obviously, they don't do a financial analysis for them, but they give initial bid. So that becomes important in these point of time. If you're looking at a commercial property, commercial property it's always dependent on tenant demand. As a large proportion of your decisions on the tenant tenant financial capabilities and on out there. Similarly, the time in such things will be coming about understanding whether the the tenant is good or not, what kind of a demand which is coming there, what kind of are they long term families which are there, or kids or students which are there, healthcare workers or temporary projects. What what is it which is coming there? That starts becoming very important to understand when you start looking at that and thinking, okay, will tenant demand rise or not for me in that area?
Mudit
Okay, from the demand angle. Now, if we talk about cash flow, let's say right now, from a cash flow perspective, let's say if somebody buying a property of 700k, there's an 80% loan, 560k. There'll be repayments. Let's say six six and a half percent interest rate. Yeah, the repayment interest alone itself be close to 3635 $36,000. Yeah, if there's a decent rental yield, let's say $600 per week, so that's close to $31,000 of income. Yeah, but if I keep all the expenses, insurance, strata, property management, property made something buffer for property maintenance, all of that. So the income is not even covering the the the interest rate itself, right? The interest I'm paying plus there are other expenses. Yeah. Yeah. So how does that
Parag Dixit
that that starts impacting? Like you rightly said, and if if I take the example which you're saying, there is a gap already which is created where your in rental income is lower than the interest which you are paying plus the cost which are going to go there, and just just imagine if I am the landlord there, and for some reason my property becomes vacant, I just my holding cost becomes terrible. Yeah, I can't I can't afford that, and at that point of time I'll start seeing okay, and maybe as an investor I should start seeing that okay whenever I buy a property whenever I get into an investment property, I'll always stress test what what's going to happen in the future. Nobody knows what the future is going to be, and I suppose nobody would have imagined we'll be in this situation a year or two or maybe six months ago as well. But you will need to know what's going to happen if property is vacant for say six weeks, six weeks, eight weeks, or whatever. If if interest rates are going to rise another 1%. What will happen to you if you lose a part of your income? Are you will you be able to find another job or not? Or if you'll not be able to find another job, what kind of a safety net which you have created for yourself? You will have to start thinking of that to be able to make a decision about whether renters are. Going to rise or not in that area, or whether you're going to be in a good situation or not. That's the same risk analysis which you spoke a little while ago. That has to come into every person when they are looking at an investment angle into a property in a particular suburb in a particular area, considering the worst case in in their mind.
Mudit
100%. So that analysis of good scenario, let's say practical scenario, but negative scenario as well, and along with that, keeping some buffer and not stretching beyond what can, which can actually start creating so much of stress in your life. Yeah, I think that that becomes very very important while making these decisions.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, absolutely right. And see, whenever a lot of times when people will come and ask us, I would always say try and keep maybe not it's not a benchmark or something, but just on a general note, try and keep up a six to 12 months of your money or your expenses in some kind of a reserve of an investment property support reserve or something. It's it's always there which will tide you over these temporary cash flow issues because it is unemployment is going rising up today, but maybe somebody losing their job can also happen in good times as well. And you will always need to have a buffer when it's when when you need to get into this. So rightly put out here.
Mudit
No, no, okay. Now, if if I look at the other side. What about let's look at the distress sales. What about them, right? So, in times where the where the unemployment is rising, can investors potentially look for distress sales and look for opportunities there? How much of that is real? How much of that can come? And if we go down that path, what are the key things to look at?
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah, yeah. You you need to you're right. So potentially, what you need to do is you need to start distinguishing between good motivated sellers and actually a market which is distressed in in which means that someone if they're selling because they are relocating or they're changing jobs or something, that's all right. That's something which is good. They are not under severe financial pressure, and that market is not going to go bad. But if the property is is doesn't have good underlying fundamentals, then it's it's not a great situation to be in. You you're not you're not looking at that property in itself as a you just looking at with a cheaper eyes, and that cheaper eyes are not going to take you anywhere when you're looking at at at at buying a property. So you look at yourself, you look at what the other person is doing. It has to match together.
Mudit
So so the goal should not be just to profit off somebody's situation. Yeah, it it is more about what is fundamentally that market and what works for both you as well as the seller.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, absolutely right. And the timing is important, right? So you can't. You nobody predicts. Nobody can ever predict that this is the bottom of the market. If everybody could predict, then that's the that would not be the bottom. Everybody would buy at that point of time. So it's it's a very different thing together. So in the end, I I I would say if I were if I were to choose, I would always say that I would need to really understand what financial situation I am in. Can I have my Plan Bs in place? And if I have my Plan Bs in place, then it's an opportunity for me. If I don't have my Plan Bs in place, then I may be in the list of distressed sellers in six months from now, and I don't want to be going into that property investment is 30 years, whether owner occupied or investment, 30 years of your time to look at that. Right?
Mudit
No, 100%. Okay, lot of lot of pointers we have discussed across from unemployment, interest rates, and sellers, and what to look at. So let's bring it together. Just to summarize, so if somebody is looking to buy, let's say in late 26, early 27. What are the key things to keep in mind? What should somebody look at?
Parag Dixit
All right, maybe I should say six things. First is obviously look at in these times, look at the unemployment trend all around you. If there is, if if it's consistently increasing, you need to be aware of that, and then then then only worry about it. It's one odd month spike here and there doesn't change much. If you're looking at job vacancies and job hiring, if there are if there are businesses around you, like you said, $300,000 300,000 more business vacancies are there in the market. If they're there in the market, businesses are recruiting. So it's not a dire market. It's not a dead market. So there is something which is happening, and then obviously interest rates and borrowing capacity, which is very important, which you guys always take care of that. Then what's happening to the arrears and the hardship arrangements around, which is happening in the area? If that area has more people struggling, and if you read from ABS and if you read from everywhere that this struggle is becoming harder and harder, and hardships are becoming harder. Then it's a problem. Fifth, maybe if depending on the days on market now, which is there in the property, what kind of inventories are there? What's the day on market showing? Is it increasing? It's how what's what's happening there? That's an important thing because if sellers are getting more and more motivated to sell and buy. Buyers are not there. We have a problem there, and then obviously rental data, rental vacancy, and what's happening in the market locally. That's important because if if the rental vacancies are also rising, then you have people a problem where people can't afford the rent, which they have to pay as well. So there is there is there is these are six things which people should have on a general look. Only when you start finding everything is getting to negative, that's where the gloom comes in. And what about the property
Mudit
prices themselves? How do you think I should look at the property prices? Because property prices are on the downward trend. So how do I analyze that along with all these six factors?
Parag Dixit
Yeah. So if you're looking at that, maybe I think a good pointer is always the recent comparable sales which you see in the market. So, if you're looking interested into particular area, particular market, particular kind of property, it's good to just not look at what's happening in the media. Just look at what's happening in the surrounding areas and what are the recent comparable sales, similar type of houses which have been sold, you know what number of houses are being sold in that area. If there is, if there is a suburb which is showing even a say a small price increase or something, but has very few transactions, that doesn't mean anything. Similarly, if it's it's the other way around, doesn't mean anything. A small change, incremental change is doesn't show a recovery or doesn't show a disaster there, which is happening there in that market.
Mudit
So, so in that case, then what would make somebody who is looking to invest more confident about buying? That okay, this is exactly what I need to do. This is where I should go.
Parag Dixit
Well, I think that their local stuff comes in there. So you need to see whether there's a good local employment, stable employment, which is there in that market. If there's rental demand, is sustainable there in that market. Supply conditions are all right; they're not changing too much, and more importantly, it fits my financial position, my financial circumstances that I can afford to do all of this. If I am prepared that if prices fall a little bit here and there, because I can't predict it's a falling market, rising market with the bottom, whatever it is, we nobody knows the point point of inflection where things will start changing. So that's all retrospective in the calculation. So till you are able to take care of all of these factors which are in your control, I think it's a it's it's a time where you can take a positive decision and start thinking of jumping into the market or starting looking at buying into the market.
Mudit
No, fair point. That that makes sense. But but then what are the key things that I as a buyer or investor should be cautious about, and and just make sure that I am I am on the right side and not risking a lot.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, I think it's completely reverse would be what I would look at. So somebody, if there's a market which is which has a rising unemployment, which is coming in there, if I am seeing a lot of distressed selling is coming in there, population data, if you get ABS data and you can start seeing, or you can start seeing a lot of people vacancies are there, a lot of houses are vacant and they're vacant for quite some time, and you can see that you will get a feel of that suburb. Then, then you look, and if just it's speculative market out there, optimistic numbers are floating around. Then I would be worried, and I would just try and keep away from those kind of markets for for investing or for purchasing.
Mudit
Okay. Now, see, a fair point. I think I I want to add on something to this that if unemployment let's say if it increases sharply okay then how will we respond right because interest rates can be taken down brought down to support the economy yeah and could those cuts I mean if they happen right will they support housing demand despite the pressure on unemployment, right? So,
Parag Dixit
okay,
Mudit
because I I think that let's say if the RBA if the if the unemployment increases sharply and the inflation is high anyways, there would be pressure on RBA to reduce the interest rates.
Parag Dixit
Okay, so yeah, so if BSB is saying okay, if unemployment rises, RBA gets forced to eventually start cutting the rates. Yes, but unemployment is also not a switch; it will just not disappear tomorrow. So, if if rate cuts happen, even though unemployment rises, maybe there will be issues which will start coming in. Correct?
Mudit
No, no, there will be. See, I think see rate cuts, if they happen, they will definitely help in terms of the property purchase price. They will stabilize that a little bit, but but then there's a catch there also because although lower interest rates, they will improve affordability.
Mudit
I'm looking to buy, my borrowing power will go up a bit again. I have a mod gage, then my repayments will go down, so it improves the affordability. But the but it doesn't just take away the the risk and the insecurity of the job. Yeah, right. That it so it so it will not restore the confidence. Yeah, a cut a rate cut doesn't restore the confidence of which is there because of the because of unemployment. And the income rising, right? So because then this creates a very different kind of market where you see that on the one hand, unemployed. I mean, the property market and employment market can just move in different directions, right? So there would be a different kind of impact on the market. It's a. It's these are moving in quite contrary to what we are used to seeing.
Parag Dixit
Yeah. Yeah. True. So true. And this will be an interesting market. This will happen, so there will be a point where RBS says that okay, unemployment is rising too much, and on and all the other factors are aligning, and let me start cutting down on the rates. And but as as you say, as you rightly said, interest rates will allow people to borrow more, but unemployment will not will keep the confidence lower, and it will not allow people to borrow itself in there, or they may not even want to borrow into this. If if let's say for like like you say, say about say if out of say 100 people which are wanting to buy, if 70 start finding that the properties are becoming affordable and they start getting into the opportunity mindset at that point of time. There may there will still those 30 people who refuse to buy. They will not buy. So lower rate cuts rate cuts can bring or stimulate a bit of demand, but it will not give you the entire thing the way you would want to do. So if I were to make three scenarios out of this, okay. Unemployment is rising; it's still rising. Inflation is falling, and rate cut is happening. That is going to stimulate the demand for sure, because people, the 70% people which we just discussed, will want will start getting into the market and say, "Okay, I am doing this. I am looking at doing this because this is an improvement about this 30% will still hold back, and this the more the 70 keeps on increasing, the more FOMO and all of that stuff keeps on kicking in. But let's say unemployment keeps on rising, the rates are falling, but confidence is just not increasing. Then this is not going to be a 7030 ratio. Then this will go into a reverse way, maybe 60-40 ratio, maybe 40-60 ratio. At that point of time, prices may just be stable or may continue to fall, even though rate cuts are happening. And in worst case, if say unemployment is also rising and the rates are also rising and inflation is also rising, then we are going into a sustained downfall, and this is the kind of market which we may be seeing in today. But this is where it will it will start creating a bit of an issue. And so, if I were to look at it, interest rates will get buyers back into the property market for sure when it starts moving down. But only and only job security will enable a lot of these people to be confident to buy into the market, rather than just be sitting on the sidelines and just doing something. So that both of these things will be very important, and confidence is more important than affordability at a lot of times.
Mudit
Okay, okay, okay. Let's let's finish it with the with the main question that we started with. And if you want to just summarize quickly, that are rising job losses killing the Australian property market, or interest rates is the bigger problem there?
Parag Dixit
Okay, maybe my my two cents in this. See, interest rates are an immediate pressure, like what we've been discussing all this while, whereas borrowing power they create an impression, immediate pressure on the on the borrowing power and on affordability and all that. But the biggest risk is unemployment. That will make my situation bad. That removes the confidence in me, and that removes the confidence in me to take an action to do any kind of an activity, higher rates can only make it harder to buy. They don't stop you to buy, but job losses make you stop to buy. They they will make it harder for you to hold on to that property, and the combination of these two things makes it very very vulnerable market in this. So I would always I would always think that we need to be really sure about what we are going to do, and maybe I I can ask you this. So if you were to look at this market like this, what would you say when you talk to so many people that people are the people confident enough to be able to buy, or the in today's market, or will they wait for the unemployment situation to become a bit better before they jump into buying in this market?
Mudit
See, the question: if it is before that, if it is that, should I wait for unemployment to come down before purchasing? I think not necessary that waiting is important there, right? It depends on a lot of factors there: income security, my own income security. What are my financial buffers? How my financials are looking like? My, how is the local employment in that area? The rental demand. What is the right price for the individual property? So there are a lot of factors.
Parag Dixit
Yeah, yeah, yeah. There are a lot of factors which come into the. You're so right. So it's it's true. When whenever we're looking at doing all of these, I think the biggest takeaway which I will have from what we've been talking all this while is interest rate will definitely definitely determine how much I can afford to buy, my borrowing capacity, and all that comes from there. But if I am not secure in my job, I'm not going to. I'm I'm not. I'm not sure that I can pay that repayment back for 30 years. I'm not going to jump into it, and I'm not going to worry about, irrespective what the price point is going to be, right?
Mudit
So I think a weaker market it can definitely create opportunities, but ultimately, and ultimately it boils down to my confidence and my financials. How much buffer I have? How much can I sustain? And based on that, if just just a lower price than what it was six months ago or three months ago doesn't make it, the reason of understanding that why is the price lower? What are the fundamentals in there? Yeah, that is what I gain from what you said. That fundamental looking at the fundamentals is very important. Not just that has dropped by 10%. Correct. What if the expectation itself was high? Yeah. So now the dropping the price doesn't matter, right? So I think it's a combination of of that, right?
Parag Dixit
Absolutely correct. No, that's that's very that's very true, and I suppose we've been able to understand what how the unemployment and the interest rates bit has been moving through, and thank you so much for contributing to all this, Madhi. And really lovely to speak to you. You've got such a great amount of experience which comes back along with it. Thank you so much. Thank you for connecting and listening to us today.
Mudit
Thank you. Bye.




